Where Lockerbie Square Grabs a Bite: Fast, Fresh & Flavorful Restaurants Around Downtown Indianapolis

Browse more Restaurants in Lockerbie Square, Indianapolis

Lockerbie Square may be one of Indianapolis’ most historic corners, but when it’s time to eat, locals and visitors are looking for something very modern: quick, satisfying food that still feels thoughtful and fresh. Within a short drive of this charming neighborhood, you’ll find an impressive mix of subs, salads, global flavors, and comfort food—all geared to busy city life.

Below is a spotlight on 10 restaurants that define the fast-casual and everyday dining scene around Lockerbie Square and greater Indianapolis, using only what they themselves promise: fresh ingredients, flexible service options, and food that fits how downtown really eats.

Subs, Sandwiches & Easy Lunches

Subway: Custom Classics Right Off Alabama

If you work or live near Lockerbie Square, the local Subway at 421 North Alabama is a familiar anchor for a quick, customizable meal. This location brings the brand’s signature Footlongs, 6" sandwiches, wraps, and salads to downtown, with fresh-cut veggies, proteins, and fresh-baked bread at the core of the menu.

You can order in several ways—through the app or online, for delivery, curbside pickup, or in-restaurant dining. They also highlight catering options and the fact that each restaurant is independently owned and operated, with local Sandwich Artists™ making it run.

Jersey Mike’s Subs: East Coast Flavor in the Midwest

For a different take on the sandwich, Jersey Mike's Subs brings an authentic East Coast-style sub shop feel to the Indianapolis area. With roots going back to the Jersey Shore in 1956, this fast-casual franchise focuses on fresh-baked bread and subs made to order.

Beyond the food, Jersey Mike’s puts a strong emphasis on community involvement and giving back. Their mission centers on serving what they call the highest quality, freshest made sub in the industry while staying active in the communities they serve—something that resonates in a neighborhood-oriented area like Lockerbie Square.

Cousins Subs: Deli-Fresh With Midwestern Roots

Wisconsin-based Cousins Subs adds another layer to Indy’s sandwich scene. Founded in 1972 and still family-owned, the brand and its franchisees run over 90 restaurants across Wisconsin and Indiana.

The focus is on deli-fresh and made-to-order grilled subs, built on their signature bread baked daily. With multiple locations in the region, Cousins provides another dependable option for Lockerbie Square residents and commuters who want a straightforward, quality sub without sacrificing freshness.

Fresh Greens & Lighter Bites

Sweetgreen: Turning “Fast Food” Into Real Food

If your idea of lunch leans more toward greens and grains, sweetgreen - Healthy Salads, Bowls and Plates in Indianapolis is built around the idea that fast food can be healthy, sustainable, and made from scratch. Their menu is centered on fresh salads, warm bowls, and hearty plates crafted from real, seasonal ingredients.

Sweetgreen describes its mission as “building healthier communities by connecting people to real food,” making it a natural fit for health-conscious downtown workers or Lockerbie Square residents looking for something quick but mindful. With additional nearby locations in places like Carmel, Fishers, and Zionsville, their Indianapolis footprint offers plenty of options if you’re on the move.

Chicken Salad Chick: Southern-Style Comfort, Lightened Up

Chicken Salad Chick brings a distinctly Southern spin to the quick-lunch category. Their specialty is chicken salad—12 flavors of it—made by hand every day using premium chicken tenderloin.

Recipes combine sweet and savory ingredients with a proprietary blend of spices and seasoning. Beyond chicken salad, they spotlight fresh side items (like grape salad and broccoli salad), homemade pimento cheese, gourmet soups, and seasonal desserts. It’s a good landing spot when you want something that feels homestyle and comforting but still relatively light compared to a heavy sit-down meal.

Global Flavors, Fast

JINYA Ramen Bar – Fishers: Slow-Cooked Broth, Lively Vibes

Ramen may not be the first food you associate with historic Lockerbie Square, but the modern dining habits of Indy residents absolutely include a good bowl of noodles. JINYA Ramen Bar - Fishers is known for a slow-cooked approach to ramen, with broths simmered in-house for 20 hours.

The menu is customizable, and the setting is described as a sleek, contemporary Japanese dining experience—great for social gatherings of all ages. For downtown Indianapolis eaters, it’s a destination spot when you’re ready to move beyond sandwiches and salads and settle in for a rich, comforting bowl.

Naf Naf Grill: A Gateway to Middle Eastern Flavors

Naf Naf Grill in Indianapolis positions itself as a guide to the best flavors of the Middle East. The menu highlights favorites like falafel, shawarma, hummus, and pillowy pita, along with scratch-made signature sauces.

Convenience is built into the experience: they offer curbside pickup, delivery, dine-in, drive-through, and takeout, which fits well with the needs of urban diners around Lockerbie Square. Their own description emphasizes discovery and hospitality—inviting guests to connect with Middle Eastern culinary traditions through generous portions and handmade dishes.

The Great Greek Mediterranean Grill: Gyros, Souvlaki & More

For a broader Mediterranean experience, The Great Greek Mediterranean Grill - Carmel, IN serves Greek, Mediterranean, and Middle Eastern-inspired classics. The menu includes grilled skewers, lamb, steak and chicken souvlaki, vibrant salads, and over-stuffed wraps.

They also point to tempting appetizers, gyros, feta fries, and indulgent desserts like baklava ice cream and Mom’s rice pudding. Available for dine-in, take-out, delivery, and catering, it’s an appealing choice when your Lockerbie Square crew wants a shareable feast with bold, sunny flavors.

Comfort Food & All-Day Dining

Metro Diner: Classic Diner Comfort Near the City

Sometimes, nothing beats a plate of diner comfort food. Metro Diner in Indianapolis leans into exactly that: award-winning comfort food and diner classics with breakfast served all day.

Signature items include Fried Chicken & Waffles and hearty meatloaf, all in a family-friendly atmosphere. With dine-in, takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup, Metro Diner suits everything from a leisurely weekend brunch to a last-minute dinner solution. For Lockerbie Square residents, it’s that reliable “feels-like-home” option just a short trip away.

Bob Evans: “Farm Fresh” Favorites Morning to Night

Bob Evans rounds out the comfort lineup with an all-day menu built around what they call “America’s Farm Fresh.” Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are available throughout the day, aimed at satisfying the whole family at a good value.

You can dine in or order online for pickup or delivery, bringing their homestyle dishes straight to your table at home. For Lockerbie Square families, it’s a dependable choice when you want classic American comfort without the work.

A Flexible, Everyday Food Scene for Lockerbie Square

What ties these restaurants together—from Subway and Jersey Mike’s Subs to Naf Naf Grill and Metro Diner—is how well they fit the rhythm of life around Lockerbie Square and downtown Indianapolis.

They offer:

Speed and convenience: apps, online ordering, curbside, delivery, and drive-through.
Range of choices: from hearty diner plates and Southern-style chicken salad to Middle Eastern bowls and health-forward salads.
Everyday reliability: consistent menus and familiar experiences you can count on during a busy workday or a packed family weekend.

Whether you’re a Lockerbie Square resident, office commuter, or visitor exploring the historic streets nearby, this cluster of restaurants ensures you’re never far from a good meal that meets you where you are—fast, fresh, and tailored to your taste.